U.S. Federal Debt: A Decade of Decisions & Fiscal Challenges Ahead

The trajectory of U.S. spending and politicians’ talk about coming to the rescue of the debt-laden U.S. economy share something in common. Both are headed onward and upward, with no meaningful solutions in sight.

Paul Ryan, former speaker of the U.S. House of Representatives, delivered that somber forecast to AMG clients earlier this month during a presentation titled U.S. Federal Debt: A Decade of Decisions & Fiscal Challenges Ahead.

But he also brought a message of hope, contending that he sees “little seeds of encouragement” from Congress, but that it likely will take an exogenous market shock like the 2008 housing crisis or an event in the bond markets to compel meaningful action, such as a Congressional commission “with real teeth” to force spending reforms.

Ryan, 53, served 20 years in Congress as a Republican from Wisconsin and was speaker of the House from 2015 until leaving public service in 2019. He was a candidate for vice president in 2012. Today, he is a partner at Solamere Capital, serves on several corporate and nonprofit boards, and is a professor at the University of Notre Dame.

As a congressman, Ryan was a self-proclaimed deficit hawk, and he remains one today, seeing the burgeoning U.S. debt as an existential threat to American prosperity.

The U.S. debt held by the public stands at $26.3 trillion today, which is about 98% of America’s projected annual GDP. That’s up from $5.8 trillion and 40.5% of GDP in 2008. And if government spending follows its current path, the Congressional Budget Office (CBO) estimates the debt will soar to 181% of GDP by 2053.

Well over half that ballooning debt will be caused by government-funded Social Security, Medicare and Medicaid programs that care for retiring Baby Boomers, the 76 million Americans born between 1946 and 1964.

That, Ryan said, coupled with elevated inflation and higher interest rates that must be paid to service the debt is already starting to constrain U.S. economic potential.

“You can’t tax your way out of this,” he said, suggesting that raising taxes alone cannot fix the looming crisis.

That’s only a small part of what needs to be done, Ryan argued. The government cannot possibly pay off the upcoming tidal wave of debt without massively debasing the currency, which could wipe out the savings and purchasing power of the American people.

America could easily fall into a “lost generation” in which income mobility, economic growth and innovation slow to a crawl, he said. It would be the first generation to be financially worse off than their parents.

He suggested that only a multi-pronged attack to balance the budget can possibly save America from potential disaster. The problem is that most politicians don’t want to address the problem because changes to Social Security and Medicare scare people who use the programs, and those folk make up nearly 25% of all voters.

“They’re afraid of blowback,” Ryan said.

First and foremost, he contended, politicians on both sides of the aisle in Washington, D.C., need to wake up and rein in the government’s massive deficit-spending spree and start chipping away at the national debt.

And the only way to do that in a meaningful way, Ryan contended, is to reweave the country’s social safety net that promises all Americans health and retirement security, primarily through Social Security, and Medicare, Medicaid and Affordable Care Act programs . Those programs are projected to consume 15.2% of GDP by 2052, according to the CBO. By comparison, the average annual cost of the entire federal government from 1972 to 2022 totaled 20.8% of GDP.

Possible solutions, he said, are included in an American Enterprise Institute book he co-edited and wrote the introduction. The collection of essays is titled American Renewal: A Conservative Plan to Save the Country’s Finances and Strengthen the Social Contact. It can be read or downloaded for free at www.americanrenewalbook.com.

Reforming Social Security is the simplest fix, Ryan said, pointing out the programs started in 1935 when the average American male could expect to live about 63 years, so that’s why the retirement age was set at 65. Today, that average life expectancy is 79 years. Ryan proposed that Congress should gradually raise the retirement age over time—one month every two years—while boosting Social Security taxes and revising means testing and wage indexing.

Medicare reform will be more difficult.

“This is the biggest driver of our debt … and the fastest growing,” Ryan said.

Ryan contends that the key to containing Medicare’s costs is to bring more choice and competition to the system. To do this, he said, Congress needs to convert Medicare to a premium-support system that works like the Federal Employees Health Benefits Program that all government workers, including elected officials, have access to.

“This effectively builds on the popular Medicare Advantage program that seniors enjoy today,” Ryan wrote in his book. “By combining the hospital insurance and supplementary medical insurance trust fund into a single Medicare Trust Fund and adding a means-testing feature to the premium support, in which the wealthy shoulder more of the premium burden than low- and middle-income seniors do, these reforms would deliver substantial savings over the long term.

“This in turn would bring substantial relief to our fiscal burden.”

If America can just start to address the debt problem, bend the debt curve so it peaks in 2040s, “this will be an awesome century.” Ryan said.

He urged all voters to take up the cause: “You have got to get serious on these issues, bone up on these issues and push your politicians, go to their events, get in their faces …

And then I’d say save money for your retirement” in case it doesn’t work out.